Skip to content
Trusted since 1983.  ·  Helping dentists and specialists achieve practice-life harmony.  ·  888.249.7537
McGill and Lyon Dental Advisory
Personal Finances

The Midterm Election Cycle is Finished– What Comes Next?

Election results naturally generate questions about the economy, taxes, and the stock market. But does one political party consistently produce better investment returns? Should investors be concerned when political control changes? Historical market data tells a more interesting story...

11/06/26 · 3 min read

The Midterm Election Cycle is Finished– What Comes Next?

By Liam Fitzgerald, CFP®*

With the midterm elections now behind us, Washington is preparing for a change in political control. Democrats have regained control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate, while Republicans will continue to hold the White House. Beginning in January 2027, the country will enter a period of divided government.

Election results naturally generate questions about the economy, taxes, and the stock market. Both political parties have different ideology on essentially every issue. But does one political party consistently produce better investment returns? Should investors be concerned when political control changes? Historical market data tells a more interesting story.

The Stock Market Has Grown Under Both Political Parties

One of the most important observations in market history is that the stock market has generated positive long-term returns under both Democratic and Republican administrations.

There have been periods of exceptional economic growth and strong stock market performance during controlling periods of both parties. For example, the S&P 500 averaged approximately 16% annually during the Obama administration and 16% during President Trump's first administration. To decipher the better performance period, you would need to go to the third decimal point. Both periods produced remarkably similar returns despite very different political agendas.

The broader takeaway is that American businesses have demonstrated an ability to grow across very different political environments.

Tax Policy: A More Predictable Environment for Practice Owners

For all dentists and particularly practice owners, tax policy is an especially important consideration and likely the most impactful to their daily lives.

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act preserved several important tax planning opportunities. These included the existing individual income tax brackets and other provisions that are particularly relevant to higher-income households and business owners.

With Republicans controlling the White House and Democrats controlling both chambers of Congress, significant changes to federal tax policy could become more difficult to pass. Neither party is likely to have an easy path to implementing its preferred tax agenda. This creates a reasonable expectation of greater tax policy stability over the foreseeable future.

This stability can be valuable when making decisions involving retirement plan contributions, Roth conversions, annual business decisions, and estate planning.

 What Actually Drives Investment Returns?

The stock market ultimately reflects the performance and future expectations of thousands of companies. For more information on drivers of market return, the November 2026 issue included an article on exactly that: Combine These Three Investment Factors for Long Term Success. Company size, valuations and profitability have the strongest impact on investment returns; not included are political parties or election results

A profitable dental practice, for example, does not suddenly become less valuable because a different political party wins an election. The same principle applies to the thousands of companies represented in a diversified investment portfolio. This is why focusing exclusively on political outcomes can cause investors to overlook the fundamentals that matter most to long-term investment performance.

Your Plan Should be Set to Succeed Regardless of Elections

There is nothing wrong with having political preferences or paying attention to changes in Washington. Elections matter, and government policies can have real economic consequences.

However, history has shown that markets can perform well under both political parties and under both unified and divided government. No political party has a monopoly on economic growth, and no election result guarantees a particular investment outcome.

For practice owners, the current political environment may also provide a period of policy predictability allowing financial planning decisions to be made with more confidence in the existing framework. Rather than attempting to predict which political party will create the best market environment, investors are generally better served by maintaining a diversified portfolio, staying disciplined, and focusing on their long-term financial objectives.

*Fitzgerald is a Financial Advisor with McGill & Lyon Wealth. He is a Certified Financial Planner® who graduated from Liberty University with a bachelor’s degree in Business Administration and a concentration in Financial Planning.